Men who are introverts prefer mundane dating settings where they are doing something relatively safe and comfortable, over doing something outside of what they are comfortable with.
When you are dating an introverted man, paying attention to doing activities he has a comfort level with matters.
It is not so much that introverted men are selfish, familiarity is where they are in their element.
An environment that is familiar to him puts him at ease, as he is either familiar with the people that hang out there or has a favorite spot at that location.
It’s in an introvert’s nature to minimize contact with people in general.
Figure out what relationship you are looking for, and make a choice of which one of the two people best fits this ideal.
Do you want a long-term or short-term relationship?
When you want a relationship that is short term, you are better off picking the person that you have the most superficial banter with.
This is the one you don’t talk to on a consistently serious level, as most of your conversations are lighthearted in nature and rarely go into deeper and more personal details.